Who's Responsible When Flock Cameras Get Damaged? - Jalopnik

A Flock camera seen against a pale blue sky

Around the World Photos/Shutterstock

If the comments under every news article and social media post about Flock cameras weren't already an indication, the rampant vandalism of the surveillance hardware should tell you all you need to know about how Americans feel about being watched 24/7. But who is responsible when Flock cameras get damaged? Who pays for the replacement and/or repairs? If you guessed "taxpayers, ultimately, because who else would it be?" pat yourself on the back.

As a real-life example, the city of Houston made headlines in July after people there cut down at least six Flock cameras in response to multiple counties renewing their contracts with the surveillance firm through 2027. But that act of defiance likely does little other than put more money in Flock Safety's pockets, because a clause in Flock's contract with at least one Texas jurisdiction, Fort Bend County, says: "In the event that Flock Hardware is lost, stolen, or damaged, Customer may request a replacement of Flock Hardware at a fee" of $500 to replace a regular pole, $2,000 for an advanced pole, and $800 for each camera. Naturally, that's paid by the county and, transitively, its taxpayers.

Pay us now or pay us later

A Flock camera at an intersection with traffic moving through.

Matthew G Eddy/Shutterstock

Around the same time, Flock published a blog post on the subject, "What Happens if a Flock Camera Is Damaged?" that details a service law enforcement agencies can opt into. "For agencies enrolled in the Camera Protection Plan, we'll repair or replace covered Flock LPR or video cameras at no additional cost when the damage occurs," the post reads. Flock describes the plan as an "optional annual add-on," which implies a recurring cost premium that isn't publicly disclosed. 

Think of it like insurance, except unlike car insurance, for example, which is provided by a third party, it's being provided by the same company that makes the thing you're insuring. But, like having to pay your ever-increasing car insurance premium each month, it's not free. Flock doesn't publicly disclose how much the plan costs, but it almost certainly ain't $0, and however much it does cost, it's ultimately coming out of the county's wallet — i.e., yours.